ScreenSpy - big news from the small screen
Don't Miss

Secret Circle hitting all the right notes, but is it too late?

By on April 22, 2012
Ashley Crow and Gale Harold in The Secret Circle. Image © The CW Network.

Ashley Crow and Gale Harold in The Secret Circle. Image © The CW Network.

The Secret Circle returned this week with ‘Crystal’ a tight, pacy romp with plenty of drama, romance and adventure – and even a brief guest appearance by TV veteran John de Lancie.

Unlike the characters in your average horror movie, The Secret Circle gang always seem to fare better when the group decides to split up, and this week’s separate paths gave rise to a tense and shocking story outcome for the adults, as well as a couple of unforgettable scenes for the younguns, including a rather touching moment between Jake (Chris Zylka) and his grandfather, (That eyebrow deserves an Emmy!) and some long overdue door-kicking, ledge-leaping, villain-tussling heroism from Adam (Thomas Dekker).

Credit is also surely due for the superbly creepy abandoned mine which not only prevented Cassie (Britt Robertson) and her half sister from entering, but which rendered all of the other witches’ powers useless. “What a great place to be normal,” as Adam points out to Melissa (Jessica Parker Kennedy).

‘Crystal’ was also the episode which dropped a double bombshell by outing Diana (Shelley Hennig) as Cassie’s secret sibling, and by killing off a character – in the form of Jane Blake (Ashley Crow). Is she really dead? Is she really really dead?

Thursday’s Secret Circle was solidly entertaining, coherent and above all, surprising. But perhaps the most surprising aspect of the episode was its poor viewing figures. TV Line reports a 36 percent fall for ‘Crystal’ resulting in a series low of 1.14 million total viewers, and a 29 percent slump in the coveted ’18-49 year olds’ demographic. So what went wrong? The hiatus certainly didn’t help. The show returned on Thursday after a two week break, which affected not only its viewing figures but that of sister show The Vampire Diaries also.

The Secret Circle has suffered from uneven story telling in previous episodes, particularly where the mechanics of the mythology of the show are concerned. In addition, Circle has struggled to make the best use of some of the large ensemble cast including Gale Harold and Adam Harrington, frustrating those who claim to ‘watch for the adults.’ However recent episodes are noticeably tighter and darker (A man exploded! What more needs to be said?) and the addition of Joe Lando as John Blackwell has served to create new story opportunities for Ethan (Harrington) and Charles (Harold) as well as raise the stakes where the younger generation are concerned.

Fans of the show are aware that Secret Circle is currently ‘on the bubble’ with its renewal status up for grabs. Much depends on the success of the remaining episodes, and the viability of a new batch of CW pilots, including the hotly tipped Arrow and The Selection.

It would be a shame to see this freshman series come to a premature end, especially now that it has found firmer footing in darker, edgier territory.

Watch The Secret Circle Thursdays at 9/8c on the CW.


  1. starlady

    April 23, 2012 at 5:30 pm

    Loved this episode. I don’t want Jane to be dead!

  2. Pingback: The Secret Circle Italia: Your best italian source about Secret Circle series.

  3. geraint

    April 26, 2012 at 12:26 am

    Gutted that Jane died, the woman who plays her is a great actress I loved her on Heroes too… I just think it would have been good to have atleast one powerful older woman there on the side of good and a good adult in Cassies life. Like Buffys mother in Buffy the vampire slayer she was awesome. I hope charles heals her with a crystal or something! 🙁 or cassie brings her back with dark magic. I hope the series gets renewed I mean i know there have been some dodgey episodes but the halloween episode and the episode where heather got possesed were brilliant and Dianna/the circle v.s Zachary at the school was an amazing scene 🙂 Vampire diaries started amazing but is now getting a bit monotonous, whereas secret circle started slow but is getting darker edgier and more exiting every week