ScreenSpy - big news from the small screen
Don't Miss

Gale Harold Talks Crime and Punishment

By on March 29, 2012

It’s 11 am in LA and I’m chatting with Gale Harold about The Secret Circle’s Charles Meade and where the show will take his character over the remaining  episodes of the current season. Initially billed as the witchy teen drama’s ‘Big Bad’ Charles has instead evolved into one of the show’s more complex and human individuals, albeit one with a couple of major misdemeanors to his name. Fans of the show will know that Charles is responsible for the deaths of both Amelia Blake and Nick Armstrong over the course of the season. In the land of TV, bad deeds rarely go unpunished for long, and I begin by asking Gale if he sees some retribution for Charles coming down the line any time soon.

“I think the most straightforward answer to that question is Charles’ retribution is to be left to be Charles, you know?” he says with a laugh. ‘Specifically? I think that something, or several things will happen. It’s just a matter of time. He’s always looking over his shoulder. Things have moved on from some loosely formed plan with Dawn to Charles being on his own. Then there’s this situation with his daughter too. If you’ve got a daughter in high school and you killed her friend’s mother …” he laughs.

“There’s always been a specific way I’ve tried to approach this show – and you may have heard this answer before – but the show is about something that’s not every day. They’re practicing something that’s outside of the social norm. I try to put my thing as close to every day reality as possible. There was all that mustache twirling, evil deed thing but that didn’t really manifest itself in the way it was originally intended to, but yes. there are definitely some things that aren’t going to be pleasant for Charles coming.”

I put it to Gale that perhaps a one-note, mustache twirling villain is less preferable to the Charles audiences have grown to know and understand this season. With many characters basically in the same place as when we first met them in the pilot, perhaps it is Charles who has undergone the greatest progression in terms of character from those opening moments.

Gale Harold: “Charles should always feel like he’s playing two or three things at the same time.” Photo by David Gray – © 2011 The CW Network, LLC. All Rights Reserved

“For me, that’s just really nice to hear,” he says. “I know we were speaking about Ireland earlier, and I’m just so late into it, but I’ve only now just seen the first two episodes of Game of Thrones. It’s such an incredibly well written show and the story behind it is so complicated that the pace at which something can develop is kind of odd. It limits itself a little. As much as you can do is completely transform in one or two episodes – or die! You can’t really move too fast.

“Charles has got kind of a cool thing because he’s sort of peripheral right? He comes in and out.  The main characters of the show are constantly up against a disaster all the time. They’re basically just trying to stay alive. It’s an odd counterpoint in a way. Even though they have all the action, they don’t have the time within it to make those character changes as much as a character like Charles on the outside can. He’s more responding to the overload as opposed to worrying about things like staying alive – or going to high school!

“I’m glad that he has that ability.  I thought that he too was going to be this big bad horrible murderer. That’s how it was presented to me initially. It evolved in a way that was slightly unexpected but it’s been fun to play.”

The cast addition of Joe Lando as John Blackwell has shifted the dynamic of the show dramatically in recent episodes. Blackwell has everyone around him under his thumb, either by force of his personality, or by blackmail or by magic. He brings an almost chess game element to each episode. Charles seems to be the only one not capable of being manipulated by him. Could this work as an advantage?

“If he plays it well it certainly could be. You’re just on the verge of seeing some interesting things,” teases Gale. “I can’t spoil too much. Blackwell is definitely using some form of blackmail. He understands and knows things. There are also things we just have to assume he knows. Charles and Dawn have history wrapped up with him. They’re just not sure how much others know what they know about him. You’re almost getting into an espionage kind of a thing ala who knows what?

What is Charles’ plan for Jane? Pictured Ashley Crowe as Jane Blake. Image © the CW Network. All rights reserved.

“With the character of Jane, I was always interested to know what happened with her because I wasn’t sure how much she knew. And I wasn’t sure how much her reactions to how much I had done to her had been a sort of poker-faced way of dealing with it.

“I know these are the kind of questions that must be so frustrating because the project is limited to a certain extent to its fan base and the people who have read the books and what they’re expecting to happen with so many of these characters. But I will say a lot of it goes to Ashley Crowe who plays Jane. She’s such a complicated actor. The way that she plays Jane I was never really sure from what she was giving where she was going, you know? Was she really nuts or was she just trying to hide something? So I had to be really careful that I didn’t go with it in advance of what it was,” he laughs.

“But this whole thing of Charles saying “I’m going to heal you. I going to do this so you’re going to help me defeat Blackwell” … it all seems like it could happen but I’m not confident that’s what we all going to find out is actually true. It’s somewhere in between what is she doing, how strong am I in making her do what I want her to do and how much control does Blackwell have over the situation already. He’s a guy with a preexisting involvement in multiple aspects of the story.

“Going back to the original question, I think that Charles –  and this is based on what you said about his demeanor and the complexity of what’s happened with him – I think that he is the classical paranoid character. He doesn’t know that he’s actually got the skill to do what he wants to do but he can’t help himself from acting out these impulses. Can he do it? He could possibly, but it all depends on how much he covers or lays things out on the table.”

Charles is becoming more isolated. He’s made an enemy of Ethan, and things look far from happy where Dawn and her plans are concerned, and obviously he hasn’t been able to share any of what he’s been up to or going through with his daughter Diana. In one sense, he seems to be standing quite alone.  Under those circumstances, might it be possible that Charles will reach out to someone as a potential ally?

“It think it would make sense that he would try to do that. I think he is definitely becoming more isolated and a lot of that has to do with Dawn. Dawn has crossed him multiple times in various problematic ways!” he laughs.

“She has, in some ways, made him believe she’s totally with him, and then where the murders are concerned, he suddenly finds himself totally on his own. She’s put him in a totally exposed position and she never backs him up. She has him do one thing and then once it’s done she crosses him behind his back. Just from that perspective he knows that he can’t trust her. So it’s a combination of things, isolated and also this incredible suspicion. So everything has to be looked at from five different angles. And that’s an even more isolated position to be in.

“Dawn has crossed him multiple times in various problematic ways” Pictured: Natasha Henstridge as Dawn and Gale Harold as Charles. Photo by David Gray – © 2011 The CW Network, LLC. All Rights Reserved

“His relationship with Diana is almost technically like a non relationship because he appears to be her father. He appears to be the one who takes care of her and that seems to be how she sees him, but he knows that he’s not able to really do that day by day, so you’re absolutely right. He’s becoming more and more isolated day by day. And I think that’s either going to result in an error on his part because of a blind spot that he has – or multiple blind spots – or it’s just gonna push him in a direction that is, for want of a better word, sloppy.”

Some recent episodes see events happening within the current Circle echoing events from the previous generation’s Circle – including a love triangle and the threat of the Witch Hunters. And of course, now we have Blackwell back and he has a foot in both Circles. I ask Gale if he thinks we’re going to see a convergence between both Circles at some point, or if there always be a separateness and a notion that the adults never quite know what their kids are up to.

“I can really only answer that question if I kind of take a more outside objective way of looking at it,” he says after a moment’s consideration. “If I was watching this as a member of the audience I wouldn’t think they could maintain that separation for an extended amount of time. It’s just with human nature and the way that life is there’s no way that that separation can be maintained. There are too many opportunities for overlap. I know that’s a very simple way of saying it, but in some way or another, either through what’s going on with Charles and Dawn or with Ethan, or more likely through Blackwell or even bad luck it’s going to happen. And once that happens if they don’t merge – if there’s not some sort of unification between the two groups, then it kind of becomes a lot like a mafia gangster type of story,” he says with a laugh.

“When two factions of the families get separated by circumstances or whatever, they’ve either got to make a deal or they’ve got to destroy each other. They can’t actually just be neighbors. They can’t just be like ‘You do your thing and I’ll do my thing. I’ll see you at the Christmas party, right? We’ll have a good time. It’ll be nice.’ You know that sort of way?”

“Yes,” I say, laughing.

“Well it can’t be that way,” he laughs. “It has to be one way or the other as soon as the information is on the table. Just from a dramatic point of view it’s gotta be heading in that direction. I don’t know when. I don’t know where. I don’t know how, but yes. I think it’s going to be a matter of how the damage control gets played through.”

I admit that I can’t actually imagine what the show will be like if it does happen. I have no concept of what that might entail.

“I know,” says Gale. “I can’t imagine how it will be resolved either, but at the same time I can’t logically see how it can go on. I don’t know how the separation can be maintained … unless there’s some massive massive spell that is put on everyone simultaneously.”

“And they all forget what happened” I offer.

“Exactly,” he laughs.

In episode 17, Curse, audiences saw Charles tell Jane he was about to restore her memory with a crystal. Isn’t that quite a dangerous move for him to make? Especially if Jane remembers that Charles and Dawn were involved in Henry Chamberlain’s death?

“Yes absolutely,” agrees Gale. “And I think that from a plot perspective and in terms of storytelling, they’re setting up great potential for drama. So, yes it’s dangerous but that’s all Charles can do. He’s aware now that Dawn made that slightly idiotic move to give Ethan a crystal. So all bets are off. She’s opened the floodgates and now the problems are just rushing in, so from that point of view Charles doesn’t really have a choice. Even if he never spoke to Dawn again he has to get back into Jane’s mind because that may be the clue. It’s a gamble.”

Gale on Charles’ relationship with Diana “He appears to be the one who takes care of her but he knows that he’s not able to really do that.” Image © 2011 The CW Network, LLC. All Rights Reserved

“That’s where it goes back to what you said earlier about it being like a chess game. I liked that analogy because where can you go? What angle can you use to move on? So absolutely. What I hope comes across with Charles – and I don’t know if this is something which is happening or not – but I think that Charles should always feel like he’s playing two or three things at the same time. A lot of that just comes down to the writing and the edit of the show. We do all kinds of things that don’t make it onscreen for time reasons. But also, I hope that’s kind of what people are feeling – that it’s dangerous, but it’s justified and that there’s some sort of relevance because [Jane] could help. If I can get back into her mind – if I can open her back up, y’know?”

The news broke last week that Louis Hunter will make a return to the show as Nick Armstrong – or some version of Nick – next season, and I tell Gale that the first person I thought of when I heard the news was Charles. There’s a lot of room for storytelling there. Does Gale foresee a Charles and Nick reunion of sorts?

“Perhaps! I can’t give you a solid answer either way but I can tell you it definitely be a very problematic thing for Charles to have to sort through if he finds himself interacting with the kid that he drowned. That to me would be very very interesting. I don’t know if that’s gong to happen but it would be great retribution. A great payback!”


Some questions were submitted to us via the Gale Harold/Randy Harrison fan website Many thanks to Aly for assembling a great list!

Time constraints meant not all questions were asked, but hopefully the answers below cover many of the bases. Thanks to everyone who took part.

Fan Question: Is there anything you ignore and you really want to know?
GH: [laughing] Um … I’m assuming this pertains to the show and not life in general?
SS: Actually, I think it might be a life in general question.
GH: [after some consideration] Well, I ignore people talking loudly on their cell phones in public places. And I want to know why they think that anyone cares what they’re talking about at that volume. And I would like to know what it would take to shut them up!
SS: I’d say that whoever sent in that question is going to be delighted with that answer.
GH: [laughing]

Fan Question: Are you involved in any upcoming projects on stage, or TV or film?
GH: In a couple of things, yeah. But it’s too early to talk about them yet. I would love to get back on stage sooner than later. At the moment there’s nothing nailed down.

Fan Question: Would you ever consider creating a Facebook or Twitter account for your fans to follow?
GH: I’ve considered it, and I have not yet but it’s … I don’t know. I’m thinking about it. I’m thinking about it.

Fan Question: Are you looking forward to the QAF Convention in Cologne this Summer?
GH: Yes. It’s going to be nice to be back with my friends. We became quite a family. I’ve never actually participated in one of these things before so I’m not sure what it’s going to be like but it’s been the one that’s been presented so far that has a real relevance to the community that we’re going to be there in support of. It seems like it’s time now.

Fan Question: Have you been to Germany before?
GH: I have. I was there once while I was in High School, and I was just there last year too. I was in Berlin for a week.
SS: Berlin is great.
GH: Oh God, it was amazing.
SS: I have some crazy memories of Berlin.
GH: [Laughing]
SS:  … And that’s all I’m willing to say.
GH: I think I know what you mean!

Fan Question: What have you enjoyed the most about filming in Vancouver?
GH: I really love being in Canada because socially, the way people behave is a nice counterpoint to the American way of life. I have some very good friends in Vancouver, one that I know from working in Toronto who is based there now, so I’ve had some great times with him. It’s also incredibly beautiful there. It’s almost overwhelmingly beautiful – too beautiful to almost exist sometimes. There’s good theaters there, and great music too. It’s just a wonderful place to be, and I many people would agree with me on that.

Fan Question: I’d like to know Gale’s size for a hat.
GH: It’s amazing that you asked me that question after you asked me about Vancouver because I have a very good friend who is based there who is a genius Milliner. But I don’t really know what my hat size is. Um … what would I be? Hold on, I’ll tell you. [Gale gets up and searches his kitchen for a hat] I have to take a look at this. I’ll just be one second. [Gale returns with a hat] I think I’m 7 and one eighth. Yeah. Seven and one eighth. That’s a US sizing. The UK is 7. And the European number is 57. [laughing]

Fan Comment: I don’t want to ask him a question. I just want to tell him that I love him, as an actor and as a human being, and that he’s a real pleasure to see on screen because he’s an incredibly good actor. I love his sense of humor and wish to see more of him in a film or a TV show (with him as the lead) but as long as he’s happy in his life (personal and professional) that’s all I’m asking for.
GH: Aww. That’s very kind. Please say thank you from me and tell them that I hope they see me on screen more as well!

Fan Question: Have you ever been to Australia?
GH: I was in Australia a long time ago. I went to Brisbane and I also spent a bit of time on the Gold Coast. I got to see the Reef a little bit, but that was a long time ago. I’d love to go back.
SS: Are you well traveled, Gale?
GH: Not nearly as much as I want to be. I still haven’t been to Barcelona. I want to go to Lisbon. I have a friend who is in Lisbon right now. I’ve never been to Argentina. I’ve never been to Brazil. Never been to Hungary, and I’ve never been to Scandinavia.
SS: Well, there’s a lot of living left to do.
GH: There is. Exactly!


  1. Lucie

    March 29, 2012 at 8:05 pm

    Wonderful! Thank you Jennifer … and Gale. 🙂

  2. verybookish

    March 29, 2012 at 8:07 pm

    Love the interview with Gale Harold!

  3. Narbeleth

    March 29, 2012 at 8:13 pm

    Very nice… Can’t wait to find out what projects may be on the way!
    Thanks so much 🙂

  4. friskyfilly

    March 29, 2012 at 8:44 pm

    Great interview. Insightful questions and gracious well thought out answers. I just love this man. He’s such a joy to watch and listen to. Thanks so much for this interview. So well done.

  5. Pingback: Gale Harold Talks Crime and Punishment with Chevron One | Kinnetiks News

  6. Pingback: New Interview: Gale Harold Talks Crime and Punishment with Chevronone « GALE DEVOTEE- A Gale Harold News Site

  7. ballymay

    March 29, 2012 at 9:05 pm

    Love Gale.

    Thanks for a wonderful interview.

  8. Marien a.k.a Brastiana

    March 29, 2012 at 9:47 pm

    Thanks for a wounderful interview I love Gale. He is a greatable actor and I with love to follow to His job and life.
    (sorry for My english if some unright I’m russian)

  9. Rach

    March 29, 2012 at 10:30 pm

    Fantastic interview! Thank you so much for the great questions and for sharing his in-depth answers. I love his amazing, thoughtful insight into his character and the show. He seems like a fun person to talk to, and I can’t wait to see him in Cologne!

  10. shari

    March 29, 2012 at 11:15 pm

    Great interview! I especially loved that you included fan questions and Gale was so willing to answer them too. 🙂 Thank you!

  11. Armand

    March 29, 2012 at 11:21 pm

    I really enjoyed the depth of analysis of the show here and Gale’s insights. His portrayal of Charles makes him a fascinating character and one I am rooting for in all the “chess games.” I especially hope he triumphs over Dawn!

  12. Kin

    March 29, 2012 at 11:34 pm

    Jennifer, you did a wonderful job with the interview! Kudos to you for asking the right questions that gave Gale the opportunity to give such insightful comments about his character and the show in general. Thank you!

  13. Pingback: Spoilers: Charles pagará por matar Nick? | Secret Circle Brasil | Círculo Secreto – Notícias, Fotos e Entretenimento # Thomas Dekker # Brittany Robertson # Phoebe Tonkin

  14. elle

    March 30, 2012 at 3:22 am

    thanks so much for the great interview!

  15. Cam

    March 30, 2012 at 5:10 am

    Always good to know about Gale Harold

  16. Ambermay

    March 30, 2012 at 6:32 am

    loved Gale since 2000 when he was in QAF! Still love him just as much and
    will watch him in anythin. Lucky for me, I like this show!!!

  17. Anna

    March 30, 2012 at 10:46 am

    My question got asked! =D YAY!!! Thank you so much for taking the time to include the fan questions! I’m sure many of us are very happy to get some answers! 🙂

  18. paceyringwald

    March 30, 2012 at 10:50 am

    This might be the best interview of Gale Harold that I have read for the last three years. Thank you so much for that. News about the Secret Circle, his possible future projects, a little insight to his peculiar mind with a beautiful narration. 🙂

  19. cybers

    March 30, 2012 at 12:08 pm

    One of the best Gale Harold interviews ever! And I totally agree with him about people who talk loudly on cellphones. *lol*

  20. susie

    March 30, 2012 at 1:21 pm

    WOW, great interview with Gale. Love it!! But why does he keep his hats in the kitchen???

  21. Pimpinette

    March 30, 2012 at 2:59 pm

    Great interview with Gale … I love this actor who has a real talent and happened to have fans to France …

  22. Pingback: The Secret Circle Italia: Your best italian source about Secret Circle series.

  23. yvonne reid

    March 30, 2012 at 6:45 pm

    Wow,Gales interview was incredible,I enjoyed reading it alot. I love him so much 🙂

  24. Magpie

    March 30, 2012 at 7:29 pm

    Chevron One, best interview yet! Loved it!

  25. Alice

    March 30, 2012 at 8:39 pm

    Chevron One and Gale Harold interview one of the best,loved it!I like and i loved Gale Harold since year 2000 QAF show,loved her too:)

  26. Kari

    March 31, 2012 at 12:53 pm

    Thank you so much for this incredible interview!! What a fascinating man! Gale, if you ever want to visit Scandinavia, I’ll be your guide 🙂

  27. Pingback: A Traitor is Revealed on The Secret Circle | Chevron One